Sunday, February 6, 2011

Fair Trade vs. Organic: Which Label Matters the Most



                                      

     On an environmental research excursion to Costa Rica, I discovered an underlying problem of the food industry: labels. Not only are labels deceiving, but they also fail to include the many factors of production. "Fair Trade" is said to guarantee fair working conditions and wages for the workers that produce our food, while "Organic" promises the perks of natural production. Is there an in-between label? Ideally, we all want the best of both worlds. Should one favor workers' rights or natural means of production? When humans' well beings are involved, it's not easy being green. One must be educated when making these important consumer decisions. I discovered my own preference after a thorough investigation of both the humanitarian side and environmental side of our food production system. 


     Visiting a conventional banana plantation at the esteemed Earth University, I realized that the people are the main focus of the company. They have an intimate relationship with the harvesting, cleaning, and shipping of the sweet yellow fruit. In fact, Earth University earned the reputation of having the most ethical banana plantation in Costa Rica by investing in $3-an-hour wages, women's rights to work, and friendly atmospheres for people to work; one can often hear lively music playing in the open-air factory as well as active production by the workers. This fair treatment of workers boasts large outputs of fruit and a long-lasting, sustainable means of production. For these reasons, big companies such as Whole Foods purchase the ethically-produced bananas to support the fair treatment of workers. The label "Fair Trade" often characterizes this type of relationship between grocery stores and food production companies. 

     Unfortunately, the bananas Earth University exported to the United States are not of organic nature; they are sprayed with a few layers of chemicals to enrich their look, because Americans would never buy a brown-freckled banana. In the banana fields, they allow two bunches of bananas to be grown, and then they proceed to stab the stem of the plant, so that a younger banana plant has a chance to grow fruit. This  is not considered a natural process, because the plant is not allowed to naturally produce or reproduce as much as it wants. The production of the bananas is not considered natural either, because the chemicals sprayed on the bananas alter the chemical composition of the banana peel and the natural brown color that accompanies the aging process. The fruit itself is altered for Western audiences so they can be sold in bulk as greenish-yellow, flawless sources of potassium. No one in America, or Europe, would be inclined to buy a brown banana, because we are taught to discard aged fruit. Little do we know, the darker colors of bananas' peels signify the sweetness that awaits us. 

      Another obstacle to the organic processing of fruit in the Tropics is a paucity of fertile soil. Overproduction of cattle and coffee years ago transformed the soil of Costa Rica into an agricultural nightmare; also, the natural fertility of the deforested tropical rainforest's soil proved to have a natural lack of organic matter. Organic, fertile matter such as manure and rotting leaves remain as components of the surface of soil. Thus, the soil could never sustain an organic, large-scale production of bananas; the plants would last for a few years, but eventually, the supply would dwindle and the economy would take a hit. People involved in the means of production could potentially lose their main sources of income, which would affect the percentage of unemployment and the way of life for many Costa Ricans. 

     This investigation led me to question whether I favored sustainable economic growth and humanitarian values over environmental downsides; as I said, it's not easy being green. In this situation, I would choose the humanitarian side. In order for people to eat and provide better lives for their children, they need a safe, sustainable mean of income. For the future, I hope organic can reach a level of sustainable, large-scale means of cultivation in the Tropics, but for now, I support the ethical, "Fair Trade" means of production. 

1 comment:

  1. This is a concise, informative and very well-organized essay, Nicole! I think we ought to use this as a sketch and develop it even further this semester. This is top-notch work.

    ReplyDelete