Sunday, March 6, 2011

A Closed Case--For Now

     Photographs like this haunt me--not because of the expression on her face, or the man's hand in the outer corner of the frame. Nor is it the heart necklace she dons that lies limp around her neck. Pure and simple, it is the fact that I took this photograph. I took a picture of a story.
     As my father and I rode through the countryside of Nepal, one rainy summer day last year, I looked out the window for one split second; it was that moment that I lifted the camera's viewfinder up to my eye and hit the trigger with my pointer finger. I figured that I captured some blurry image that had rapidly raced past me, for we were going so fast. But it wasn't so. The picture was clear cut--almost too vivid. I had captured a photograph of a man grabbing a young woman seemingly forceful and without her consent.
     Did I capture these people in these poses on accident? Was I making a story out of nothing? Or was this happening real? I wonder sometimes if photographers can frame certain scenarios on accident or on purpose. We see it in the tabloids all the time with unflattering images of the most beautiful celebrities and film stars. The tabloid photographers are searching so broadly for a story, that they create one out of one accidental shot. I don't want to believe the story that I see here, because I can't support it with the story behind it.
     Photography often falls into a tricky area of ethics. For instance, travel photographers can run into a dilemma of exploitation in portraits, because the subjects don't always have a part in the publishing process of the photography. If I wanted to, I could publish a whole article on the patriarchal society that dictates Nepal's social order and gender roles, but I can't ethically do so. I may have had a riveting story, but I would never have the truth. In fact, the very reason I chose to explore photojournalism is to bring the truth of the world back to my little hometown. Everyone deserves the truth. I want to give the couple a fair shot in my photographic archive, but I can't put this in an article, because I'd be violating my own moral code. If I had all the time in the world to go back to Nepal and ask the Nepalese couple about their photograph and what it may mean. It's actually on my bucket list. But for now, this picture remains in a closed file, ready to be opened with the facts.

No comments:

Post a Comment